top of page

Who Needs Knee Replacement Surgery? – Dr. Mayur Rabhadiya

Understanding When Knee Replacement Surgery Is Necessary

Knee replacement surgery is not required for everyone with knee pain or arthritis. It is recommended only when knee joint damage leads to persistent pain, functional limitation, and reduced quality of life, despite appropriate non-surgical treatment.

Dr. Mayur Rabhadiya is an Orthopedic & Joint Replacement Surgeon in Mumbai, with focused expertise in knee replacement surgery, helping patients understand when surgery is beneficial and when it can be safely delayed.

About Dr. Mayur Rabhadiya – Knee Replacement Specialist in Mumbai

Dr. Mayur Rabhadiya specializes in hip and knee replacement surgery and consults patients from Ghatkopar East, Ghatkopar West, and across Mumbai.

His approach to knee replacement decision-making emphasizes:

  • Accurate diagnosis and grading of arthritis

  • Evaluation of symptoms and daily functional limitation

  • Exhausting appropriate non-surgical options first

  • Clear explanation of risks, benefits, and expectations

  • Recommending surgery only when it offers meaningful improvement

Common Reasons Patients Need Knee Replacement Surgery

Knee replacement may be recommended when patients experience:

  • Persistent knee pain affecting walking or daily activities

  • Severe stiffness limiting movement

  • Progressive knee deformity (bow-legs or knock-knees)

  • Reduced walking distance and endurance

  • Poor sleep due to knee pain

  • Limited benefit from physiotherapy, medications, or injections

The decision is based on symptoms and function, not age alone.

How Severe Does Knee Arthritis Need to Be?

Knee replacement is usually considered when:

  • Arthritis is advanced on X-ray

  • Joint space is significantly reduced

  • Pain is frequent and disabling

  • Quality of life is clearly affected

However, X-ray findings alone do not determine the need for surgery. Some patients with severe X-ray changes may still manage without surgery, while others with moderate changes may require intervention.

Who May Not Need Knee Replacement Yet?

Knee replacement can often be delayed in patients who:

  • Have mild to moderate pain

  • Can perform daily activities with manageable discomfort

  • Respond to physiotherapy and medications

  • Have early-stage arthritis

In such cases, non-surgical treatment is preferred.

Age and Knee Replacement Surgery

There is no fixed age limit for knee replacement surgery.

Knee replacement may be considered:

  • In younger patients with severe symptoms and functional limitation

  • In elderly patients who are medically fit and limited by knee pain

The decision is based on health status, symptoms, and functional needs, not age alone.

What Happens If Knee Replacement Is Delayed?

Delaying knee replacement may lead to:

  • Worsening pain and stiffness

  • Reduced mobility and muscle strength

  • Progression of deformity

  • Increased difficulty in rehabilitation later

However, surgery should not be rushed. The timing must balance symptom severity with overall health and readiness.

How the Decision for Knee Replacement Is Made

The decision to proceed with knee replacement involves:

  • Detailed clinical examination

  • Review of imaging studies

  • Assessment of pain severity and lifestyle impact

  • Discussion of non-surgical options

  • Understanding patient expectations

A shared decision-making approach ensures appropriate timing of surgery.

Why Choose Dr. Mayur Rabhadiya for Knee Replacement Evaluation in Mumbai

  • Focused expertise in knee and hip replacement surgery

  • Conservative, evidence-based recommendations

  • Clear explanation of when surgery is truly needed

  • Willingness to advise against surgery when appropriate

  • Structured long-term joint care planning

Consult to Understand If You Need Knee Replacement Surgery

If you are unsure whether knee replacement surgery is right for you, or have received differing opinions, you can consult Dr. Mayur Rabhadiya for a clear, unbiased evaluation and guidance.

bottom of page